• Home
  • Forums
  • Register
  • Featured
  • Reviews
  • Guides
  • Contact

[Review] Gigabyte P67A-UD7 VS ASUS Maximus IV Extreme – Battle of the Titans!


Posted by miahallen on 27 Jan 2011 / 20 Comments
Tweet



Introduction

If you haven’t already seen our complete Asus Maximus IV Extreme (MIVE) motherboard review, Parts ONE and TWO, you’re missing out. Part 1 covered synthetic testing with the i7 2600K CPU at 5.1GHz to give an idea of the power that this platform contains. Part 2 was a full blown comparison between X58 and Sandy Bridge, with a helping of AMD Thuban for good measure. We also awarded the MIVE the TechREACTION.net Gold Silicon award for its outstanding performance.

Today, we’ll give you a look at another top P67 choice; the Gigabyte P67A-UD7. Currently it is the top choice for Sandy Bridge users looking for Gigabyte flavor in their builds. This will be a true head-to-head comparison between the two motherboards’ performance, overclocking, and ease of use factors. All of these things are important for enthusiasts in this market, so with luck, Gigabyte will meet and exceed our expectations in regards to these features with the UD7. Read on…

Gigabyte P67A-UD7

Gigabyte P67A-UD7

V.S.

Asus Maximus IV Extreme

Asus Maximus IV Extreme

Both of these boards represent each company’s premier P67 offering at this time. They each support numerous USB3.0 ports, dual NICs, triple SLI and top quality components. Each company has attempted to infuse a plethora of overclockinging features to keep all enthusiasts, from gamers to hardcore overclockers, happy and…well…enthused. Each claims to be the best, but there is only one problem with that; they both cannot be the best. This statement creates a conundrum, but never fear; TechREACTION is here!


Next: A Closer Look At The P67A-UD7

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6

Written by miahallen

Well, I was playing with computers ever since my Dad got a Commodore 64 when I was 6 years old (1986), when I was 10 (1990) he bought a custom build 486DX33, and I was in love. Mostly back then I was just a kid playing games, but my fascination with computers had a start. Because I had no money of my own, I was stuck playing with my Dad's computers, and really couldn't "play" too much. So in 1998, the year I graduated, I spent some of my college savings to by a "computer for school", haha. It had two Voodoo2 12MB 3D accelerators in it, so you can imagine how much school work was done on it ;-) It had an AMD K6-233 that I had a really mild OC on, but my custom computer builder friend Aaron had done all the work. So I can't really take the credit there. My fascination with graphics just kept growing and growing over the years, and I was constantly in a struggle to keep my games looking as sharp and smooth as possible. OCing played a big role. My whole world was rocked in 2004 when I was deployed to Iraq as a US Army soldier. The whole year I was there I had a cheap IBM Thinkpad R40 with a 2GHz Celeron, 1GB DDR-333 RAM, a 60GB 4200RPM HDD, and ATI Radeon Mobility graphics (same technology as a 7000 series with only 16MB of memory). It started out rough as I was really into Command and Conquer Generals at the time, and the machine would only play the C&C slide show LOL. So, I downloaded PowerStrip, and OC'ed the GPU by 40%...amazingly, the game was playable! Things changed dramatically in 2007 when I met a guy named Matt while I was stationed in Japan. He introduced me to www.ocforums.com, and the "Benchmarking Team" there. I had not had much interest in benchmarking previously, I always though of myself as more practical. But, I thought I'd play along and I joined the team. My first introduction to an actual competition was was is "The Raptor Pit", "Forum Warz 2008" in the spring of 2008. I was running a Q6600 and an 8800GTX. With air cooling I was able to bench my Q6600 at over 4GHz, and tore up the competition in my class. Overall OCF won the Forum War in 2007, Winter and Summer of 2008, and 2009...that means five in a row. I was not part of the first one in 2007, but the four since then, I have participated in. After winning the 2008 Winter and Summer Warz, Tom's Hardware Guide announced they were looking for nominations for individuals to compete in their first ever international overclocking competition, called "Overdrive". I was nominated, and chosen to compete in the North American semi-finals in Los Angeles in November 2008. I was placed on "Team IRONMODS" as they only had two guys, yet three man teams were allowed. We won the semi-finals in LA, and our prize was a trip to Paris the following month, to compete with the best in the world. The following month, Ton, Jake, and myself flew to Paris as "Team USA" to face off against the best from Taiwan, France, Germany, and Italy. It was a very intense competition, but after two heated days of battle (16 hours of benching), we emerged the victors. Amidst our celebration, Ton and Jake officially invited me to join "Team IRONMODS" on a permanent basis, and I graciously accepted. Ton, aka "TiTON", is a world renown case moder, and is also very well known for some of the AMD overclocking he has done. Jake, aka "CPT.Planet", is a genius overclocker, and a really fun guy. The team has a great synergy when working together, we really have complementary styles. After winning the world championship in December 2008 things were a bit quite for a couple months, then in the spring of 2009 I received an invitation to the 2nd annual Gigabyte Open Overclocking Championship "GOOC". I would compete in the North American semi-final in LA, where the winner would win a ticket to the world championship in Taipei Taiwan during CES in June 2009. The competition was tough with 14 of the best from North America gathering for a 1 on 1 competition of OCing. But once again, I completed the competition well, and rose above the others. I won 1st place and the trip to the world finals in Taipei. My luck ran dry in Taipei where I started off with a bad motherboard, and went through 5 more during the course of the competition due to various reasons. Despite the poor finish in Taipei, I have high hopes to redeem myself next year.

20 Comments


http://Sayyesweddingsofficialblogsite.Blog.com
2 months ago



“[Review] Gigabyte P67A-UD7 VS ASUS Maximus
IV Extreme – Battle of the Titans! | TechREACTION” was indeed a remarkable article and
thus I was in fact extremely satisfied to locate the
blog. Thank you,Simone

Today's News Headline
2 yearss ago



Very illuminating post…

[Thread Ufficiale] Nvidia GTX 590 - Pagina 23 - Xtreme Hardware Forum
2 yearss ago



[...] bridge tramite i due canali x8. Quindi con due schede video non fa altro che causare overhead. In questa recensione viene infatti mostrato come la MIVE riesca ad avere un piccolo vantaggio sulla UD7 grazie agli [...]

mobo 1155 oc - Pagina 2 - Forum di Tom's Hardware
2 yearss ago



[...] avere 16x/16x devi usare il secondo e il quarto slot … ma ci perdi rispetto a 8x/8x guarda qua [Review] Gigabyte P67A-UD7 VS ASUS Maximus IV Extreme – Battle of the Titans! | TechREACTION [...]

miahallen
2 yearss ago



I reach the same maximum speeds on both boards. BIOS revisions can have a huge difference though, so another site claiming a big variance between them probably aren’t using the optimal BIOS version on each.

Papoulka
2 yearss ago



But which one overclocks better? I plan to put in a 2600K with a good air cooler and run the clock up as much as is easy and practical. I think Overclockers3D did this and found tha the Gigabyte P67-UD7A went a couple hundred MHz further than the Maxiumus IV. That matters.

Aside from that, I’d take the Asus. It’s oversize (a negative) but it does come with a full suite of fan control headers with both manual and thermal controls on most of them. The GB board in comparison has *nothing*, which is idiotic.

schede madri, fasi alimentazione, induttanze ecc. ecc. - Xtreme Hardware Forum
2 yearss ago



[...] le schede sulla cpu. il risultato in termini prestazionali sembra confermato da questa comparativa: [Review] Gigabyte P67A-UD7 VS ASUS Maximus IV Extreme – Battle of the Titans! | TechREACTION Rimane il fatto che queste schede sono del tutto inutili se non utilizzati per un tri-way sli o [...]

Maximus IV SLI Help! - Overclock.net - Overclocking.net
2 yearss ago



[...] be looking for a flexible SLI bridge that will reach from slot x16_1 to slot x16_3. This review REVIEW says Slots x16_1 and x16_2 give the best 3D results. Better than using 1 & 3 native. It was in [...]

Question about Asus Maximus IV Extreme - Overclock.net - Overclocking.net
2 yearss ago



[...] see answered, since I'm after this same MoBo. I'll share what I've been able to find: Check here: http://www.techreaction.net/2011/01/…-the-titans/3/ This is the closest I've been able to come to an answer. It shows the results of using the Maximus [...]

P67 NF200 vs no-NF200 SLI/CF - Overclock.net - Overclocking.net
2 yearss ago



[...] http://www.techreaction.net/2011/01/…-the-titans/3/ found it UD7: MIVE: __________________ Are the VRMs on my AMD motherboard high quality?Team 13 "It's better to be lucky than good!" function showHide(what){ a=what.getElementsByTagName("div")[0]; if(a.style.display=='none'){ a.style.display='block'; }else{ a.style.display='none'; }} Click below to show/hide hidden for your safety Quote: [...]

Gigabyte P67A-UD7 vs Asus Maximus IV Extreme - Page 3 - Overclock.net - Overclocking.net
2 yearss ago



[...] are always better to make a choice then opinions of random people who don't even own both borads. http://www.techreaction.net/2011/01/…of-the-titans/ And the Asus Maximus won over the UD7. [...]

Prime85
2 yearss ago



Great review guys! Picking up UD7 though. Great board!

2 yearss ago



[...] [...]

miahallen
2 yearss ago



Thanks for the comments Michael…I’d agree the Gigabyte board can be frustrating to overclock at times, hopefully with future BIOS updates it will get better.

MichaelTurbo
2 yearss ago



I love Gigabyte & ASUS for high-end boards. I currently incorporate the Crosshair IV Extreme for AM3 & upgraded from P55A-UD7 to one of those featured here, the P67A-UD7. Incidentally, I had ordered a Maximus Extreme for the P55 .. but the website, having listed it as in stock, ended up being full of it & required I wait several weeks for updated inventory. So that being said, I really am all about these brands.

In deciding on the P55 Gigabyte device, I began with uncertainty. I really, really hated the color scheme..but, as far as running triple-crossfire it was a virtual match for ASUS, so it looked good in functionality terms. After receiving it, I was forever sold on Gigabyte boards (as it was $50+ cheaper, as a benefit) Until a month ago, that was the best overall board I’d owned.

It’s mainstream successor, though, as far as features & build quality surpasses everything I’ve yet worked with. And by no slim margin. Intermittent overclocking failure will result in a frivolous, automated back-up bios flash; and yes, this is excruciatingly irritating (not to mention the poorly slotted pci-e x1 being unusale). The BIOS software error is going to be remedied after this version succeeds the beta phase, Irrelevant nuances aside, It’s featured of a software bios error, though, & in spite of it I’ve managed a 24.7 5.1 GHz overclock under 1.5 mV. I’m converting to water cooling the CPU/3x GPUs so it’s important to note I’m getting these brilliant numbers BEFORE integrating a high-end heat radiation system.

Very nice review, by the way. I’ve never used the ASUS board so I’ll refrain from engaging performance / component discourse. They’re both exceptional though. Keep up the good work ya’ll.

miahallen
2 yearss ago



Thanks for the feedback both of you :-)

BelowMe
2 yearss ago



I owned the UD7 here for awhile but am returning it and waiting for the MIV. Why? Asus simply makes better quality boards. That’s not to say GB is crap.. the UD7 is great, but mine had a lot of minor issues. Just like this review states, you can’t go wrong with either board. Also, it might be worth mentioning in the review that the UD7 is “uEFI Bios Ready” and will more than likely be receiving that upgrade soon. Overall, impressive review and I have added this site to my Google Reader feed.

computerfixbychris
2 yearss ago



I have the MAXIMUS! It is hands down the best mobo I’ve ever seen. I have a quad overclocked to 3.85 and it isn’t breaking a sweat. I mean that too, top temp is 35c. Never use the full potential of this board its amazing, but already technology is changing and it will be old news soon too. They all do. I have tried both these boards several times, yet I believe the gigabyte board is great and find zero flaws, I still feel ASUS builds a longer lasting quality board, and nothing I mean nothing is cooler than showing off the big red glowing (gamer republic logos) that light up on the board even when its off. Even off its a badass. ;)

Gigabyte P67A-UD7 VS ASUS Maximus IV Extreme – Battle of the Titans! @ TechREACTION | The SSD Review
2 yearss ago



[...] Story @ Tech Reaction Posted in: Affiliate [...]

The Duke
2 yearss ago



Ooooo, UD7 and Silverstone Raven 03 anyone? That would be a great black/gold looking combo! :)

Great write-up Miah! A lot of good info in there for the people trying to decide which route to go.


Leave a Reply

  Cancel Reply


subscribers

0

followers

Visit the TechReaction.net Forums
  • Sponsor


  • Find us on Facebook

  • Sponsors

  • Popular Categories

    Adapters AMD Apple ATI Audio Cases Cloud Computing Contests Cooling Displays DVD Events Extreme Featured Gaming Guides HTPC Hyper-v Intel Interviews Memory & Storage Microsoft Mobile Modding Motherboards & Chipsets Networking Nvidia Overclocking Peripherals Portable Devices Power Supplies Previews Processors PS3 PSP Reviews Site News Software Storage Uncategorized Video Video Cards Web XBOX 360
  • Categories

    • AMD (120)
    • Apple (9)
    • ATI (43)
    • Audio (40)
    • Cases (128)
    • Cloud Computing (3)
    • Contests (2)
    • Cooling (124)
    • Displays (2)
    • Events (23)
    • Extreme (54)
    • Featured (130)
    • Gaming (51)
      • PS3 (3)
      • PSP (3)
    • Guides (31)
    • HTPC (15)
    • Hyper-v (1)
    • Intel (103)
    • Interviews (1)
    • Memory & Storage (109)
    • Microsoft (14)
    • Mobile (5)
    • Modding (32)
    • Motherboards & Chipsets (82)
    • Networking (6)
    • Nvidia (42)
    • Overclocking (159)
    • Peripherals (104)
    • Portable Devices (36)
    • Power Supplies (14)
    • Previews (23)
    • Processors (64)
    • Reviews (365)
    • Site News (40)
    • Software (19)
    • Storage (5)
      • Adapters (3)
    • Uncategorized (58)
      • DVD (2)
    • Video (5)
    • Video Cards (51)
    • Web (2)
    • XBOX 360 (3)



Copyright © 2012 TechReaction.net - PC Hardware Reviews, Guides, How-To's and News.